9.5 piston pump vs plunger pump

piston pump vs plunger pump

Piston pump vs plunger pump:-When it comes to pumps, there are several types available in the market, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages.This article covers the plunger vs piston pump.

Types of possitive displacement pump

There are main two types.

• Reciprocating pump
• Rotary pump

Two popular types of positive displacement pumps are piston pumps and plunger pumps. While both of them have similar working principles, there are some key differences between the two. In this article, we’ll explore the differences between piston pumps and plunger pumps, their advantages and disadvantages, and their applications.

What is a Piston Pump?

A piston pump is a type of positive displacement pump that uses a reciprocating piston to move fluid.

Diagram of piston pump 👇

The piston is driven by an external power source, such as an electric motor or an engine. As the piston moves back and forth, it creates a vacuum on one side, which draws in the fluid, and then pushes it out through the other side.

Advantages of Piston Pumps

One of the biggest advantages of piston pumps is that they can generate high pressures. This makes them suitable for applications that require high-pressure output, such as in hydraulic systems or pressure washing equipment. Additionally, piston pumps are generally more efficient than other types of pumps because they do not require a lot of energy to operate. They also have a relatively long lifespan compared to other types of pumps.(piston pump vs plunger pump)

what is difference between piston pump vs plunger pump ?

Disadvantages of Piston Pumps

Piston pumps are more expensive than some other types of pumps, and they require more maintenance than other types of pumps due to their complex construction. Additionally, they are not suitable for handling viscous fluids or abrasive materials, as these can cause damage to the piston and other components.(plunger vs piston pump).

What is a Plunger Pump?

A plunger pump is another type of positive displacement pump that uses a reciprocating plunger to move fluid. Like a piston pump, it creates a vacuum on one side of the plunger to draw in the fluid and then pushes it out through the other side.

Plunger pump diagram

Advantages of Plunger Pumps

Plunger pumps are well-suited for handling abrasive materials and high viscosity fluids, making them ideal for applications such as water treatment, chemical processing, and oil and gas production. They are also more affordable than piston pumps, making them a popular choice for low-pressure applications.

Disadvantages of Plunger Pumps

One of the main disadvantages of plunger pumps is that they generate less pressure than piston pumps. Additionally, they are not as efficient as piston pumps, and they have a shorter lifespan.

Applications of Piston and Plunger Pumps

Piston and plunger pumps are used in a wide range of applications across various industries. Piston pumps are commonly used in hydraulic systems, pressure washing equipment, and water treatment systems. Plunger pumps, on the other hand, are often used in chemical processing, oil and gas production, and water treatment applications.

difference between piston pump and plunger pump

Parameter	Piston Pump	Plunger Pump
Operating Principle	Uses reciprocating piston(s) to create pressure and move fluid.	Uses reciprocating plunger(s) to create pressure and move fluid.
Types	Single Acting, Double Acting	Single Plunger, Duplex Plunger, Triplex Plunger
Flow Rate	Medium to High	Medium to High
Pressure	High Pressure (Up to 700 bar)	High Pressure (Up to 1000 bar)
Applications	Used in oil and gas, water treatment, chemical processing, and other industrial applications.	Used in agriculture, car wash, high-pressure cleaning, and other commercial and industrial applications.
Maintenance	Requires regular maintenance and lubrication.	Requires regular maintenance and cleaning.
Cost	Typically more expensive than plunger pumps.	Typically less expensive than piston pumps.
Efficiency	Generally less efficient than plunger pumps.	Generally more efficient than piston pumps.
Noise	Can be noisier due to the reciprocating motion of the piston.	Can be quieter due to the stationary nature of the plunger.
Wear and Tear	Can experience wear and tear on the piston and seals due to the high-pressure and reciprocating motion.	Can experience wear and tear on the plunger and seals due to the high-pressure and reciprocating motion.
Seal Life	Generally shorter seal life compared to plunger pumps.	Generally longer seal life compared to piston pumps.
Priming	Requires priming before use.	Can be self-priming or require priming depending on the model.
Safety	Can be hazardous due to the high-pressure operation.	Can be hazardous due to the high-pressure operation.
Flexibility	Can handle a wide range of fluids and viscosities.	Can handle a wide range of fluids and viscosities.
Size and Weight	Can be larger and heavier than plunger pumps due to the need for larger pistons.	Can be smaller and lighter than piston pumps due to the use of smaller plungers.
Control	Can be controlled using various methods such as frequency converters and variable speed drives.	Can be controlled using various methods such as pressure switches and unloader valves.

difference between piston Pump and plunger pump

Note: The above comparison is based on general characteristics and may vary depending on the specific make and model of the pumps.

QNA on piston pump vs plunger pump

Question: What is the main difference between piston pumps and plunger pumps?

Answer: Piston pumps use a reciprocating piston to move fluid, while plunger pumps use a reciprocating plunger.(piston pump vs plunger pump).

Question: Which type of pump is more suitable for handling abrasive materials?

Answer: Plunger pumps are better suited for handling abrasive materials(piston pump vs plunger pump)

Question: What is the primary advantage of piston pumps?

Answer: Piston pumps can generate high pressures, making them ideal for high-pressure applications.

Question: Which type of pump is generally more efficient?

Answer: Piston pumps are generally more efficient than plunger pumps.

Question: What is the primary disadvantage of plunger pumps?

Answer: Plunger pumps generate less pressure than piston pumps and have a shorter lifespan.

Question: What are some common applications of piston pumps?

Answer: Piston pumps are commonly used in hydraulic systems, pressure washing equipment, and water treatment systems.

Question: What are some common applications of plunger pumps?

Answer: Plunger pumps are often used in chemical processing, oil and gas production, and water treatment applications.

Question: Which type of pump is more expensive?

Answer: Piston pumps are generally more expensive than plunger pumps.

Question :- Can piston pumps handle high viscosity fluids?

Answer – Piston pumps are not well-suited for handling high viscosity fluids.

Question :- How do piston and plunger pumps work? A

Answer:- Both pumps use a reciprocating motion to draw in fluid and then push it out through the other side, creating pressure.

Conclusion

This article covers the piston pump vs plunger pump.Both piston pumps and plunger pumps are effective positive displacement pumps with their unique set of advantages and disadvantages. While piston pumps are ideal for high-pressure applications, plunger pumps are well-suited for handling abrasive materials and high viscosity fluids. Understanding the differences between these two types of pumps can help you select the right pump for your application and ensure that it operates efficiently and effectively.

Read Also,

types of pump

gear pump

horizontal centrifugal pump vs vertical centrifugal pump

Reference,

piston pump vs plunger pump

plunger vs piston pump